Leeds United’s impressive victory over Chelsea was not without controversy, with a contentious penalty decision providing plenty of debate during and after the game at Stamford Bridge.
The incident divided opinion among pundits, with questions raised over whether the referee had made the correct call and whether VAR should have intervened.
Alan Shearer was among those who disagreed with the decision, while another former Premier League player explained why the original verdict was ultimately allowed to stand.
Shearer disagrees with penalty decision in Leeds win

Speaking live on BBC Final Score, presenter Jason Mohammad relayed Shearer’s immediate reaction to the incident, with the former Newcastle striker watching from elsewhere in the studio while working on Match of the Day.
Mohammad said: “That’s the key thing, Michael Oliver has made the on-field decision. Alan Shearer, I’m hearing, is also saying ‘not a penalty’.”
Shearer’s verdict added to the debate surrounding the decision, which went against Chelsea during their defeat to Leeds.
Former Manchester City defender Nedum Onuoha also questioned the call, describing it as a terrible decision. However, he acknowledged that overturning the referee’s original verdict was always going to be difficult once Michael Oliver had pointed to the spot.
Onuoha explains why VAR did not overturn the call

Onuoha believed the problem for VAR was the lack of conclusive evidence to demonstrate that Oliver had made an incorrect decision.
He said: “I genuinely think that’s a terrible decision, because the referee’s given it; they’re looking at the evidence, and they can’t find the exact angle that shows it wasn’t a handball.”
He went on to explain why the on-field decision was likely to survive the review.
“They’ll be looking at the video and asking, is there any concrete evidence? And I don’t think they’ve been able to hit that mark, so they’ve said we’ll have to stick with the decision.”
The comments highlight the distinction between whether a decision is considered correct and whether there is enough evidence for VAR to overturn it. Onuoha clearly felt the penalty should not have been awarded, but believed the review process left little room for intervention.
For Leeds, the controversy will not take away from an outstanding 4-1 victory at Stamford Bridge. The Whites ended a 26-year wait for an away win against Chelsea, although the penalty incident ensured the result came with plenty of talking points.